CRITERIA FOR ASSESSMENT
Objectives:
To strengthen
your ability to analyze the effects of different speaking styles on different
audiences.
Steps:
1. Observe a speaker outside of class. Select a speaker and setting unlike those to which are you most accustomed.
2. Seek advance permission to attend if it is not a public event. You need to observe the rules of the occasion as well.
3. Write the “speaker observation” paper. Read the paper assignment thoroughly before the speech, so you will know to what to play close attention. You should take notes at the speech; you may wish to tape it, if you have permission to do so.
4. This paper should be typed, double-spaced, at least 2 papers in length, using 12 or 14 font with normal margins.
Speaker Observation Paper:
1. Give the following
information at the top of your paper:
Your name, name of speaker, and specific occasion
Date, time and location of speech
Title or
main purpose of speech
2. Analyze the speech according to the following seven speech categories. Use the subtopic continuums to assist your writing, discussing those that apply. Where along the continuum would you place the speaker, compared to other speakers you have seen?
3. Discuss other subtopics appropriate to what you observed.
Speaker Attitudes
Emotional
to detached
Proud to
indifferent
Using humor
and wit to not using humor and wit
Personal
flair and flamboyance to restrained formal style
Voice and Articulation
Fluent
to choppy
Loud to
soft
Rhythmic
to nonrhythmic
Dynamic
to restrained
Bodily Postures
and Action
Broad movements
to limited movements
Many gestures
to too few gestures
Much eye
contact to limited eye contact
Language
Flowery
to unadorned language
Highly
verbal to concise language
Aggressive
to deferential language
Rhythmic
to nonrhythmic language
Descriptions
that are direct and explicit to descriptions that are indirect and implicit
Content
Many examples
and stories to few examples and stories
Many facts
to few facts
Much use
of Western logic to limited use of Western logic
Objective
description of the topic to subjective description of the topic
Talking
about self to not talking about self
Aggressively
persuasive to accommodating
Organization
Linear
to nonlinear organization (identify organizational structure – historical,
spatial, topical, etc.)
Audience
What was
the reaction of the audience to the speaker
What was
the demographic make-up of the audience